New York City
Columbus Crew
Games: 27
Goals: 94
History
Columbus Crew
4 - 2
New York City
Columbus Crew
2 - 1
New York City
New York City
2 - 3
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
1 - 1
New York City
New York City
1 - 1
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
3 - 2
New York City
New York City
2 - 0
Columbus Crew
New York City
4 - 1
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
2 - 1
New York City
New York City
1 - 2
Columbus Crew
New York City
1 - 2
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
3 - 1
New York City
New York City
1 - 0
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
1 - 0
New York City
New York City
1 - 0
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
2 - 2
New York City
Columbus Crew
2 - 1
New York City
New York City
2 - 0
Columbus Crew
New York City
2 - 0
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
4 - 1
New York City
New York City
2 - 2
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
2 - 3
New York City
New York City
4 - 1
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
3 - 3
New York City
Columbus Crew
3 - 2
New York City
New York City
1 - 2
Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
2 - 2
New York City