History
New York City
3 - 1
FC Cincinnati
FC Cincinnati
1 - 0
New York City
New York City
3 - 2
FC Cincinnati
FC Cincinnati
4 - 2
New York City
FC Cincinnati
1 - 0
New York City
FC Cincinnati
3 - 0
New York City
New York City
1 - 3
FC Cincinnati
FC Cincinnati
1 - 0
New York City